The Case

At the time Jennifer Fay went missing, unspeakable horror was unfolding a few blocks away in the home of Diana Natale -- the same home were some believe Jennifer was buried that night in 1989.

On February 4th, 2021, 23-year-old Sandra Birchmore was found dead in her apartment by the Canton Police. The Medical Examiner ruled it a suicide but friends and family have their doubts.

19 months later, three Stoughton Police officers have resigned including one who is the last known person to see Sandra alive.

Steve Robinson

Kirk Minihane

Diana

It's January 3rd, twenty twenty one, and we're in the backyard of thirty six Broad Street in Brockton, Massachusetts, where some believe Jennifer Fay's body was buried on November 14th, 1989. She was last seen no more than 50 yards from this home. Private investigators who have worked this case for 

Kirk provides an update to Season 2's case involving Sandra Birchmore. It was reported yesterday in the local media that two sources are claiming that DNA testing shows Matthew Farwell was not the father to Sandra Birchmore's unborn child.

Season 2: Sandra Birchmore Story Update

Matthew Farwell was arrested Wednesday and arraigned in Federal Court on charges of killing Sandra Birchmore. Farwell first engaged with Birchmore when she was a 13 year old Stoughton Police Explorer. According to court documents filed Tuesday, Farwell strangled Birchmore to death after being told he was the father of her child.

Matthew Farwell Indicted On Charges Of Killing Sandra Birchmore

Kirk sits down with Turtleboy to discuss the the familiar faces in the death of Sandra Birchmore and the Karen Read trial.

Follow The Case on Twitter, Instagram & TikTok @TheCasePodcast. For more information about The Case, visit TheCasePodcast.com. If you have information about Sandra Birchmore or anything related to this case, you can reach us on all social platforms or email us at TheCase@barstoolsports.com 

You can find every episode of this show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or YouTube. Prime Members can listen ad-free on Amazon Music. For more, visit barstool.link/thecasepodcast

Update: A Talk With Turtleboy About Sandra Birchmore and Karen Read

In the Season Two finale of The Case, Kirk describes the hurdles in pursuing justice for Sandra Birchmore. Some new information has come to light from the crime scene and Sandra's family representatives continue to amend the wrongful death lawsuit following new information brought forth in this podcast. 

Follow The Case on Twitter, Instagram & TikTok @TheCasePodcast. For more information about The Case, visit TheCasePodcast.com.

If you have information about Sandra Birchmore or anything related to this case, you can reach us on all social platforms or email us at TheCase@barstoolsports.com

A Noble Failure

Police Exploring has been around since the 1950's through the Boy Scouts and its subsidiary Learning for Life. The programs purpose is to introduce youth to Law Enforcement but its history is plagued by sexual abuse and misconduct. It's this program where Sandra Birchmore met Matthew Farwell & other police officers who took advantage of her and ultimately led to her death.

Follow The Case on Twitter, Instagram & TikTok @TheCasePodcast. For more information about The Case, visit TheCasePodcast.com.

If you have information about Sandra Birchmore or anything related to this case, you can reach us on all social platforms or email us at TheCase@barstoolsports.com

Explorers

Barstool Sports Homepage

This layout is the Featured section for barstoolsports.com and the Barstool iOS app.

Featured Section

Slot 1

Slot 2

Slot 3

This layout is the home feed section for barstoolsports.com and the Barstool iOS app.

Feed Section

Chicago Is An Elite Bachelor Party Destination In America And Here Is Your Definitive Guide.

Slot 4

Slot 10

Pardon My Take

<p>On "Pardon My Take," Big Cat &amp; PFT Commenter deliver the loudest and most correct sports takes in the history of the spoken word. Daily topics, guests, and an inability to tell what the hosts might be doing will make this your new favorite sports talk show. This is a podcast that will without a doubt change your life for the better- guaranteed, or your money back. *Pretend a reggaeton air horn is going off right now* PMT.</p>

On "Pardon My Take," Big Cat & PFT Commenter deliver the loudest and most correct sports takes in the history of the spoken word. Daily topics, guests, and an inability to tell what the hosts might be doing will make this...

Chicks In The Office

On Chicks in the Office, Ria and Fran keep you in the know on all things pop culture. The Chicks are the go-to source for entertainment news, TV and film recaps, and interviews featuring some of your favorite celebrities.

On Chicks in the Office, Ria and Fran keep you in the know on all things pop culture.

Chicks in the Office

Spittin' Chiclets

<p>Former NHL vets Ryan Whitney, Paul Bissonnette, Barstool Sports writer Rear Admiral and Producer Mike Grinnell bring their outspoken and irreverent opinions to the masses. Focusing on the NHL but also touching on pop culture and everything else under the sun. New episode every Tuesday.</p>.

Rear Admiral, Ryan Whitney, Paul Bissonnette, and Mike Grinnell team up to bring their outspoken and irreverent opinions to the masses. Focusing on the NHL...

Spittin Chiclets

The Yak

Kyle "KBNoSwag" Bauer and his legion of friends; Nick, Brandon Walker, Rone, Lil Sas, Kate, Steven Cheah and Big Cat gather each weekday at 1PM ET Live on the Barstool Yak YouTube to talk about exclusively the most important topics of the day. This is the podcast version of that show. 10x.

Fore Play

"Fore Play" is a weekly podcast by common golfers, for common golfers. Trent, Riggs, Frankie, Dan Rapaport, and their wide variety of guests talk about everything golf like normal folks sitting at a bar watching coverage, venting about the game's difficulties, and weighing in on pro gossip. Your classic golf addicts, the "Fore Play" crew brings a young, unique voice to the rapidly-evolving game, discussing freely and openly everything golf. There is nothing like it.

"Fore Play" is a weekly podcast by common golfers, for common golfers. Trent, Riggs and their wide variety of guests talk about everything golf like normal folks sitting at a bar watching coverage, venting about the game's...

Son of a Boy Dad

Lil Sasquatch recently dropped out of college and is rudderless in this big mean world. To help fill in the gaps on the education he missed, he leans on his producer Rone to help him craft a healthy worldview and teach him what it means to be a man

Macrodosing

Macrodosing is a twice weekly macrodose of knowledge on topics ranging anywhere from your favorite conspiracy theory to deep dives on historical events. With PFT Commenter and Arian Foster at the helm of their cast of characters, the only criteria for this podcast is that we tickle your brain.

Macrodosing: Arian Foster and PFT Commenter

Mostly Sports

Mark Titus and Brandon Walker talking sports... mostly. Streams live on Mostly Sports' YouTube Channel M-F at 10AM ET/9AM CT, hits the podcast feed shortly after. 

Subscribe on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@MostlySportsTitusandWalker?sub_confirmation=1. 

Follow Mostly Sports on Twitter: https://twitter.com/MostlySports 
Follow Mark on Twitter: https://twitter.com/clubtrillion 
Follow Brandon on Twitter: https://twitter.com/bfw 

Follow Mostly Sports on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/mostlysportsshow/ 
Follow Mark on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/marktheshark34/ 
Follow Brandon on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/bwalkersec/ 

Follow Mostly Sports on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@mostlysportsshow?lang=en 
Follow Brandon on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@brandonfwalker?lang=en 
Follow Mark on TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@marktituspod?lang=en

Mostly Sports With Mark Titus and Brandon Walker

The Dog Walk

Welcome to The Dog Walk hosted by Eddie from Barstool Sports. This is a quick hitting 15-20 minute show that touches on all walks of life. From conspiracies to learning about different jobs or the everyday banter it's a perfect fit for the middle of your day. We got you covered on The Dog Walk.

Welcome to The Dog Walk hosted by Eddie from Barstool Sports. This is a quick hitting 15-20 minute show that touches on all walks of life. From conspiracies to learning about different jobs or the everyday banter it's a perfect fit for the middle of your

BFFs

Welcome to BFFs with Josh Richards & Brianna Chickenfry! Join Bri and Josh each week as they give an inside look on their lives and friendship. From vlogging their experiences to sitting down and having raw conversations with each other and special guests, subscribe to stay updated on all things BFFs!

Featured

Cities

Sports

Barstool Brands

Sports

Cities

Trending

Diana

Episode Description

More Podcast Episodes

The Case

June 13th, 2025 · 13 min

The Case

August 29th, 2024 · 30 min

The Case

June 19th, 2024 · 47 min

The Case

January 24th, 2023 · 21 min

Advertisement

More Pods Like This

Unfiltered. Unapologetic. In Your Inbox.