Dumping Them Out – Is The Big Ten The Deepest Conference in College Football?


Welcome back to another episode of Dumping Them Out. Happy week before Thanksgiving. Or as I like to call it, National 20% Off Everything in The Barstool Store Day. Everyone's favorite Twitter day of the year.

What a fantastic weekend for Big Ten football. Nebraska finally gets its ranked win over Ohio State. Washington takes down the mighty Indiana Hoosiers. The Michigan Wolverines are BACK!
For years, it's been nothing but a small handful of the classic Big Ten powerhouses dominating the top of the conference. Ohio State, Oregon, Indiana. Sometimes Michigan wins a National Championship. Penn State had a football team up until last season. But each year, whoever the two or three best teams were, they were the obvious contenders, and they beat up on the rest of the Big Ten. But not this year. This year, the Big Ten is deep. In 2026, middle-of-the-pack teams like Iowa, Washington, Nebraska, even Minnesota and Illinois can hang with the big dogs. Michigan still has the best defense in college football. For once, the Big Ten is strong top to bottom. Better bring your A-game every week when you play in the Big Ten, or else you're gonna get got.
Sorry, I was trying to do a sarcastic SEC thing. That's what you have to do in college football, though, right? Push narratives? LSU is about to finish the season .500, yet every team that beats them gets a hard-fought quality win. And any team they beat simply fell victim to the best conference in football. God, I really hate doing this. Being a college football fan is exhausting.


Advertisement

Imagine if the SEC just lost every game in the college football playoff this year? Imagine if, like, Boise State boat-raced Texas in the first round. And Wake Forest beats Tennessee, then goes on to beat Georgia in the quarterfinals. And Alabama loses to like, BYU or something. Wouldn't that be the most satisfying thing to ever happen in all of sports? Damn… I can only dream.


But that's not going to happen (probably). It's not that I don't think the SEC is the best conference. It's just that I don't think the SEC being the best overall conference should get them quite so much leeway with the committee. College football shouldn't build the entire sport on who Vegas thinks would win on a neutral site. But every year we seem to trend more and more in that direction. There's gotta be a better middle ground in there somewhere. Whatever. It's about to be all for nothing this year anyway… I think. If Alabama, Texas, and Tennessee all finish with 2 losses, there's no argument against them being in the playoffs. The only real bullshit thing that could happen (SEC-wise) would be one of those 2-loss SEC teams getting a third loss and somehow getting in over a 2-loss Wake Forest or Texas Tech (whose second loss only came because they played in the conference championship). A 2-loss BYU should get in ahead of them too, considering one of their losses was a close game vs. #2 Utah. But if the SEC takes care of business, any drama with who gets the last playoff spot won't have shit to do with them. I'll be like… 2-loss Indiana vs 2-loss BYU or something. God damn it… I'm gonna have to fight a Mormon, aren't I?

Advertisement



How about UCLA's quarterback making what might be the #1 all-time most frustrating play I've ever seen with my own two eyes?

Advertisement
Goodness gracious. For a third-string quarterback too… who's the little brother of the injured first-string quarterback… who was thrust into the game when it mattered most because UCLA's second-string quarterback was carted off the field… that's brutal. You can't help but feel bad for the kid. Madden Iamaleava was in way over his head last night. But also, when you're a third-string quarterback, I feel like tucking and running should be the #1 thing on your mind. No matter how much of a joke Michigan is on offense, that defense is crazy good. If they give you a sliver of daylight, don't think twice. Just tuck your head and go.
Fuck… I'm just now realizing this… is the Big Ten about to fuck around and get zero teams into the playoffs? Wait, never mind. That can't happen. The Big Ten winner gets an automatic bid. But I think the committee is going to give UCLA the 2023 Florida State treatment and drop them ALL the way out because they have no capable quarterbacks left. And then what happens? If UCLA loses to USC next weekend, and UCLA, Indiana, Iowa, and Oregon all end up with 2 conference losses, we then get an Oregon-Iowa Big Ten Championship game. That's actually kind of cool. I'd be happy to see Iowa win it. Then maybe Indiana could sneak in with 2 losses? Damn… that's really the Big Ten's path to getting 2 teams in, isn't it? It's the Big Ten winner, then maybe a 2-loss Indiana.
OR a 2-loss Iowa, if UCLA beats USC next weekend. Then the Big Ten Championship would be UCLA vs Oregon. Meaning the winner of that game would get in, then it comes down to if the committee wants to give Indiana or Iowa one of the last spots.
Boy… the Big Ten has a hell of a situation on its hands. And I've barely started considering what happens if other SEC, ACC, or Big 12 teams get upset next weekend. But hey… that's life in the Big Ten – The deepest conference in college football. That is the narrative I choose to go with.


Advertisement


