Debate: What's The Hardest Sport To Ref?

Icon Sportswire. Getty Images.

Boys and girls, let’s have a little fun today. It’s a beautiful Friday here in Chicago the sun is out, it’s a perfect 80 degrees, and I can already see people lining up outside the bars. It’s one of those glorious days that just feels right. So, why not kick off some classic bar talk right here on the blog?

Let’s have a debate: What’s the hardest sport to referee?

We’ll start with the NBA, because honestly, being an NBA referee might be the worst job in all of sports. These refs are constantly involved in the action. Every call or non-call feels like the wrong decision to someone. You blow the whistle, someone’s mad. You let it go, someone’s even more mad. There’s no winning. And the players suck. Sure, refs in every sport get chirped, but no one complains to the officials more than NBA players. Outside of soccer, these guys are the most dramatic athletes on the planet, always flopping, always crying, constantly lobbying for calls like it's part of the game. Add to that the physical grind of sprinting up and down the court all game long? Absolute nightmare.

Now, NFL refs don’t have it quite as bad, but their job still sucks. Technically, they could call holding on nearly every play. The game is so fast and physical, and with rule changes seemingly every year in the name of player safety, half the time it feels like they’re inventing new penalties on the fly. But the worst part is NFL refs are under massive scrutiny. You miss a call in an NBA game on a random Tuesday night? It’s forgotten by morning. But screw up a call in the NFL and it's all anyone talks about for the next week. ESPN, Twitter, barbershops, blogs, you name it. That one call lives forever.

MLB umpires, on the other hand, have it relatively easy. Sure, being a home plate ump is no joke. Calling balls and strikes on 100 mph fastballs is insane, I don't even know how they do it. But overall, they’re standing still for most of the game, and the pace is slower. You don’t see the same level of chaos and constant decision making.

Soccer refs? Meh. Not going to spend too much time there. With all due respect, their job feels more about endurance than decision-making. Sure, there's some flopping and gamesmanship, but outside of a few controversial offside or penalty calls, it's a manageable gig.

And that brings us to the true heavyweight: hockey.

Hockey refs have the toughest job in all of sports, hands down. Think about it, a long shift for an NHL player is over a minute. That’s it. But refs? No shifts. They're on the ice for the full 60 minutes, skating nonstop. The game is fast, physical, and played in tight spaces and you have to track not only the puck but every slash, hook, and trip across a giant sheet of ice, all while dodging players flying around at 30 mph.

It’s by far the most physically demanding sport to officiate, and for that reason alone, I’m crowning it the hardest.